banner-image
banner-image
banner-image
banner-image
My Pet Monster Amtoy 1986 Vintage

My Pet Monster Amtoy 1986 Vintage

$500.00$250.00

Vintage AmToy Lot Of 5 Super Pickle, Super Banana, Hot Dog, And Burger

Vintage AmToy Lot Of 5 Super Pickle, Super Banana, Hot Dog, And Burger

$149.99$75.00

NEW Vintage Amtoy The Get Along Gang Clip-ons Bingo Beaver 1984 MOC

NEW Vintage Amtoy The Get Along Gang Clip-ons Bingo Beaver 1984 MOC

$12.99$6.50

Vintage My Pet Monster Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Cuffs Amtoy 1986 ~ Nice Color!

Vintage My Pet Monster Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Cuffs Amtoy 1986 ~ Nice Color!

$299.90$149.95

Vintage 1980 AMTOY Super Pickle Plush Stuffed Toy

Vintage 1980 AMTOY Super Pickle Plush Stuffed Toy

$29.99$14.99

Vintage 1986 Amtoy 24” MY PET MONSTER Plush Original Stuffed Animal W/ Cuffs

Vintage 1986 Amtoy 24” MY PET MONSTER Plush Original Stuffed Animal W/ Cuffs

$299.99$150.00

1985 SKULL FACE Madballs Series 1 AMTOY Complete Vintage

1985 SKULL FACE Madballs Series 1 AMTOY Complete Vintage

$99.99$49.99

Vintage 1983 AmToy Plush Super Banana Clip On with Cape and Shoes Super Hero

Vintage 1983 AmToy Plush Super Banana Clip On with Cape and Shoes Super Hero

$39.42$19.71

AMTOY - Orig. 1982 Trade AD / ADVERT _ Great Space Coaster _ Peanut Butter Jelly

AMTOY - Orig. 1982 Trade AD / ADVERT _ Great Space Coaster _ Peanut Butter Jelly

$19.99$9.99

Vintage 1980 AmToy 14" Super Pickle Plush Very Clean Collectable

Vintage 1980 AmToy 14" Super Pickle Plush Very Clean Collectable

$75.00$37.50

Vintage 1980 Amtoy Lucky Pups White Puppy Dog 8” Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

Vintage 1980 Amtoy Lucky Pups White Puppy Dog 8” Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

$13.50$6.75

1985 SCREAMIN MEEMIE Madballs Series 1 AMTOY Complete Vintage

1985 SCREAMIN MEEMIE Madballs Series 1 AMTOY Complete Vintage

$84.99$42.49

HTF NOS Vintage 1986 MY PET FOOTBALL MOSTER Plush AmToy NEW!! Handcuffs

HTF NOS Vintage 1986 MY PET FOOTBALL MOSTER Plush AmToy NEW!! Handcuffs

$989.99$495.00

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original No Cuffs

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original No Cuffs

$249.00$124.50

Amtoy Baby SoftTouch Clown Doll Plush Chimes Pink Yellow American Greeting 1982

Amtoy Baby SoftTouch Clown Doll Plush Chimes Pink Yellow American Greeting 1982

$189.95$94.97

Vintage 1980 Amtoy Long Fellow Monkey Ape Plush With Tags And Scarf.

Vintage 1980 Amtoy Long Fellow Monkey Ape Plush With Tags And Scarf.

$75.00$37.50

VTG 1984 Amtoy Playtime Burger Plush Hanging Rare Stuffed Toy Plush Cheese Korea

VTG 1984 Amtoy Playtime Burger Plush Hanging Rare Stuffed Toy Plush Cheese Korea

$19.44$9.72

Vintage AMTOY Sweet Delights Ice Cream Plush Toy American Greetings

Vintage AMTOY Sweet Delights Ice Cream Plush Toy American Greetings

$45.00$22.50

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Plush AmToy Big 24” Original Stuffed Animal

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Plush AmToy Big 24” Original Stuffed Animal

$170.00$85.00

Vintage 1983 Amtoy Super Pickle Stuffed Figurine Plush 6"

Vintage 1983 Amtoy Super Pickle Stuffed Figurine Plush 6"

$49.99$25.00

Madballs Oculus Orbus Vintage 1985 Original Series Amtoy Eyeball Madball

Madballs Oculus Orbus Vintage 1985 Original Series Amtoy Eyeball Madball

$150.00$75.00

MadBalls Horn Head AMTOY 1985 Monster Gross Weird Ball Toy 4” Cyclops Vintage

MadBalls Horn Head AMTOY 1985 Monster Gross Weird Ball Toy 4” Cyclops Vintage

$45.00$22.50

Amtoy My First Puppy Vintage Rare Plush 80s Stuffed Animal Dog Toy

Amtoy My First Puppy Vintage Rare Plush 80s Stuffed Animal Dog Toy

$195.00$97.50

The Great Space Coaster Goriddle Gorilla 20” Plush No Box 1981 Amtoy See Pics

The Great Space Coaster Goriddle Gorilla 20” Plush No Box 1981 Amtoy See Pics

$58.00$29.00

Rare Vintage 1984 Amtoy Clip-On 6" Frank E. Footer - Plush Toy Hot Dog

Rare Vintage 1984 Amtoy Clip-On 6" Frank E. Footer - Plush Toy Hot Dog

$14.99$7.50

Vintage 1983 AMTOY American Greetings Clip-On Pencil Hugger Plush Girl Doll

Vintage 1983 AMTOY American Greetings Clip-On Pencil Hugger Plush Girl Doll

$4.89$2.44

Vintage 1984 Amtoy Sweet Delights Vanilla Ice Cream Plush Toy American Greetings

Vintage 1984 Amtoy Sweet Delights Vanilla Ice Cream Plush Toy American Greetings

$38.99$19.50

Amtoy Super Pickle 1980 Morgan Ind.

Amtoy Super Pickle 1980 Morgan Ind.

$55.00$27.50

Vintage Amtoy DOLL Yellow BUNNY RUBBER FACE Soft Touch Terry Cloth 80's SEE ALL

Vintage Amtoy DOLL Yellow BUNNY RUBBER FACE Soft Touch Terry Cloth 80's SEE ALL

$185.99$93.00

Vintage AmToy Baby Biggie Bear Biggsy Boy Plush 24” Jumbo Stuffed Bear Blue

Vintage AmToy Baby Biggie Bear Biggsy Boy Plush 24” Jumbo Stuffed Bear Blue

$54.00$27.00

AmToy 1986 My Football Monster Plush 24" Vintage Rare

AmToy 1986 My Football Monster Plush 24" Vintage Rare

$199.99$100.00

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Plush AmToy Big 24” Original Stuffed Animal No Cuffs

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Plush AmToy Big 24” Original Stuffed Animal No Cuffs

$189.99$95.00

My Pet Monster -- WOGSTER -- Amtoy

My Pet Monster -- WOGSTER -- Amtoy

$23.99$11.99

AMTOY 1986 MADBALLS SWINE SUCKER

AMTOY 1986 MADBALLS SWINE SUCKER

$100.00$50.00

My Pet Monster 24" Plush | Partial Cuffs | Stuffed Animal | Vintage AmToy 1986!!

My Pet Monster 24" Plush | Partial Cuffs | Stuffed Animal | Vintage AmToy 1986!!

$300.00$150.00

Vintage 1983 Frank E Footer Hot Dog Stuffed Plush Toy American Greetings Amtoy

Vintage 1983 Frank E Footer Hot Dog Stuffed Plush Toy American Greetings Amtoy

$9.99$5.00

1986 SNAKE BAIT Madballs Series 2 AMTOY Complete Vintage

1986 SNAKE BAIT Madballs Series 2 AMTOY Complete Vintage

$99.99$49.99

Vintage Floppalots Polkadot Dog Patchwork Yarn Quilted Plush 1987

Vintage Floppalots Polkadot Dog Patchwork Yarn Quilted Plush 1987

$24.99$12.49

Vintage My Pet Monster Little Meathead 1987 Plush Yellow Extremely Rare HTF 80s

Vintage My Pet Monster Little Meathead 1987 Plush Yellow Extremely Rare HTF 80s

$300.00$150.00

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original No Cuffs

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original No Cuffs

$200.00$100.00

Vintage Wolf Breath Madballs Toy 1986 AmToy Series 2 Foam

Vintage Wolf Breath Madballs Toy 1986 AmToy Series 2 Foam

$96.00$48.00

RARE Vintage Amtoy Popples DUFFLE BAG Pink Popple Bag 1986 WITH Rare MINI PLUSH

RARE Vintage Amtoy Popples DUFFLE BAG Pink Popple Bag 1986 WITH Rare MINI PLUSH

$64.99$32.49

Amtoy 1986 Popples Sticklers Puffball Popple Very Rare

Amtoy 1986 Popples Sticklers Puffball Popple Very Rare

$39.95$19.98

Vintage 1980s Super Pickle and Mrs. Fickle Pickle Clip-On Amtoy Stuffed Toys

Vintage 1980s Super Pickle and Mrs. Fickle Pickle Clip-On Amtoy Stuffed Toys

$49.00$24.50

Vintage MADBALLS Ad Poster Amtoy GROSS!

Vintage MADBALLS Ad Poster Amtoy GROSS!

$6.00$3.00

My Pet Monster -- GWONK -- Amtoy

My Pet Monster -- GWONK -- Amtoy

$48.00$24.00

Amtoy Vintage Holly Hobbie 13" Ragdoll

Amtoy Vintage Holly Hobbie 13" Ragdoll

$31.50$15.75

Vintage Madballs Aargh 1985 Original Amtoy Ball Baseball Squish Toy See Pic READ

Vintage Madballs Aargh 1985 Original Amtoy Ball Baseball Squish Toy See Pic READ

$39.88$19.94

Vintage Amtoy Floppalots Lion Plush 1980s Yellow Orange Yarn & Cloth

Vintage Amtoy Floppalots Lion Plush 1980s Yellow Orange Yarn & Cloth

$25.00$12.50

SCROUNGY Vintage 1981 Plush Dog- American Greetings AmToy Stuffed Animal

SCROUNGY Vintage 1981 Plush Dog- American Greetings AmToy Stuffed Animal

$39.95$19.98

Vintage 1986 AmToy My Pet Football Monster

Vintage 1986 AmToy My Pet Football Monster

$119.99$59.99

VINTAGE MARVEL STAR 1986 MADBALLS #1 VG NEWSSTAND ISSUE COMIC BOOK AMTOY TOYS

VINTAGE MARVEL STAR 1986 MADBALLS #1 VG NEWSSTAND ISSUE COMIC BOOK AMTOY TOYS

$19.97$9.98

NEW Get Along Gang Montgomery the Moose STICKLES Sticker Figure Toy NOS Amtoy

NEW Get Along Gang Montgomery the Moose STICKLES Sticker Figure Toy NOS Amtoy

$31.96$15.98

Vintage AMTOY Bear Terry Cloth Plush Rattle Baby Toy Crib Wrap 7" 1986 *Read

Vintage AMTOY Bear Terry Cloth Plush Rattle Baby Toy Crib Wrap 7" 1986 *Read

$9.99$5.00

Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Pet Football Monster 24" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Big EUC

Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Pet Football Monster 24" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Big EUC

$224.99$112.50

Vintage 1982 AmToy Plush Super Banana Clip On

Vintage 1982 AmToy Plush Super Banana Clip On

$29.99$14.99

NEW Vintage 1983 SUPER PICKLE Mrs. Fickle Pickle AmToy Plush Clip On

NEW Vintage 1983 SUPER PICKLE Mrs. Fickle Pickle AmToy Plush Clip On

$74.99$37.49

Vintage 1985 AmToy My Pet Monster 24” Large Plush Original - No Cuffs

Vintage 1985 AmToy My Pet Monster 24” Large Plush Original - No Cuffs

$274.99$137.50

MY PET MONSTER Plush with Handcuffs and Breakaway Chain AmToy 1986 READ V158

MY PET MONSTER Plush with Handcuffs and Breakaway Chain AmToy 1986 READ V158

$299.99$150.00

Tuggabows 1986 Plush Girl Pink Yarn Hair AmToy TCFC Vintage Doll

Tuggabows 1986 Plush Girl Pink Yarn Hair AmToy TCFC Vintage Doll

$12.00$6.00

Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

$47.99$24.00

Amtoy Super Nut Peanut Plush 1984 American Greetings Vintage Toy Flawed 6.5 Inch

Amtoy Super Nut Peanut Plush 1984 American Greetings Vintage Toy Flawed 6.5 Inch

$23.00$11.50

1988 Amtoy Crib Pals Baby Toy Plush clown vintage vtg cute colorful

1988 Amtoy Crib Pals Baby Toy Plush clown vintage vtg cute colorful

$13.95$6.97

Vintage Swine Sucker Madballs Toy 1986 AmToy

Vintage Swine Sucker Madballs Toy 1986 AmToy

$69.99$34.99

Vintage AmToy Bedtime Sleeping Teddy Bear Plush American Greetings 1982 12”

Vintage AmToy Bedtime Sleeping Teddy Bear Plush American Greetings 1982 12”

$13.50$6.75

My Pet Monster 1986 Plush Amtoy WITH CUFFS Handcuffs Hand Blue Vintage Retro

My Pet Monster 1986 Plush Amtoy WITH CUFFS Handcuffs Hand Blue Vintage Retro

$450.00$225.00

Test Sample Prototype TCFC 2016 Mad Balls Madballs Series Vinyl Figure Amtoy

Test Sample Prototype TCFC 2016 Mad Balls Madballs Series Vinyl Figure Amtoy

$19.99$9.99

Bruise Brother Vintage 1986 AmToy MADBALLS HEAD POPPERS Action Figure

Bruise Brother Vintage 1986 AmToy MADBALLS HEAD POPPERS Action Figure

$80.00$40.00

Monster Hugger 6139 (Vintage My Pet Monster, AmToy)

Monster Hugger 6139 (Vintage My Pet Monster, AmToy)

$94.95$47.48

The Get A Long Gang Clip Ons Lot Of 4

The Get A Long Gang Clip Ons Lot Of 4

$16.99$8.49

Vintage 1986 Super Madballs Touchdown Terror Football - Toy - Original 15b2

Vintage 1986 Super Madballs Touchdown Terror Football - Toy - Original 15b2

$114.99$57.49

Vintage Rare Pink 1987 AmToy Brush-A-Loves Plush Great Condition

Vintage Rare Pink 1987 AmToy Brush-A-Loves Plush Great Condition

$50.00$25.00

Brush A Loves Beauty Berry Pink Blue Plush Bear 1987 Amtoy - FLAW

Brush A Loves Beauty Berry Pink Blue Plush Bear 1987 Amtoy - FLAW

$35.00$17.50

Vtg AmToy American Greetings 10" Curly Red Hair Ballerina Doll 1982 Strawberry

Vtg AmToy American Greetings 10" Curly Red Hair Ballerina Doll 1982 Strawberry

$5.24$2.62

Vintage Madballs Aargh 1985 Original Amtoy Ball Baseball Squish Toy See Photos

Vintage Madballs Aargh 1985 Original Amtoy Ball Baseball Squish Toy See Photos

$85.00$42.50

Vintage 1987 AMTOY Stuffed Animal Purple Pink BRUSH A LOVES Plush Rare 80s Toy

Vintage 1987 AMTOY Stuffed Animal Purple Pink BRUSH A LOVES Plush Rare 80s Toy

$33.49$16.75

1984 Get Along Gang AmToy Portia The Porcupine Hugger Figure Vintage Toy

1984 Get Along Gang AmToy Portia The Porcupine Hugger Figure Vintage Toy

$10.00$5.00

Vintage 1983 Amtoy Mrs Fickle Super Pickle American Greetings Toy Cucumber Plush

Vintage 1983 Amtoy Mrs Fickle Super Pickle American Greetings Toy Cucumber Plush

$29.99$14.99

Vintage Super Banana Amtoy 1982 Plush Rare

Vintage Super Banana Amtoy 1982 Plush Rare

$99.99$49.99

AMTOY - Original 1987 Trade AD / poster _ My Pet Monster _ Madballs _ Tuggabows

AMTOY - Original 1987 Trade AD / poster _ My Pet Monster _ Madballs _ Tuggabows

$29.99$14.99

AMTOY 1983 TEAM MATES CLIP ONS HOMER BASEBALL BOY MOC UNUSED SUPER PICKLE PAL

AMTOY 1983 TEAM MATES CLIP ONS HOMER BASEBALL BOY MOC UNUSED SUPER PICKLE PAL

$24.99$12.49

Gwonk 1986 My Pet Monster Hand Puppet Amtoy Vintage NO Handcuffs

Gwonk 1986 My Pet Monster Hand Puppet Amtoy Vintage NO Handcuffs

$59.99$30.00

Pretty Petals Amtoy 1985 Flower American Greetings Vintage RARE

Pretty Petals Amtoy 1985 Flower American Greetings Vintage RARE

$114.98$57.49

MAD BALLS 1985 BASH BRAIN Crack Head vintage Amtoy madballs moc baseball

MAD BALLS 1985 BASH BRAIN Crack Head vintage Amtoy madballs moc baseball

$248.95$124.47

1986 Aargh Madball VINTAGE (AmToy)

1986 Aargh Madball VINTAGE (AmToy)

$429.99$215.00

Brush A Loves Vintage Tuttie Cutie 1985 Plush Stuffed Animal Teal Pink AmToy

Brush A Loves Vintage Tuttie Cutie 1985 Plush Stuffed Animal Teal Pink AmToy

$49.99$25.00

Vintage 1986 Amtoy American Greetings My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush

Vintage 1986 Amtoy American Greetings My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush

$42.71$21.36

MadBalls Horn Head AMTOY 1985 Monster Troll Gross Weird Ball Toy 4” Cyclops vtg

MadBalls Horn Head AMTOY 1985 Monster Troll Gross Weird Ball Toy 4” Cyclops vtg

$55.00$27.50

MADBALLS ROLLERCYCLE HORN HEAD 1986 AMTOY ROLLER CYCLE MAD BALLS TRIKE CATAPULT

MADBALLS ROLLERCYCLE HORN HEAD 1986 AMTOY ROLLER CYCLE MAD BALLS TRIKE CATAPULT

$325.00$162.50

Amtoy Baby Softtouch 12" Plush Clown Toy Lovey Rattle Chimes Vintage 1982

Amtoy Baby Softtouch 12" Plush Clown Toy Lovey Rattle Chimes Vintage 1982

$19.99$9.99

RARE Vintage Amtoy Popples DUFFLE BAG Blue Popple Bag 1986

RARE Vintage Amtoy Popples DUFFLE BAG Blue Popple Bag 1986

$45.00$22.50

1986 Super Madballs Touchdown Terror Football Toy Original Vintage

1986 Super Madballs Touchdown Terror Football Toy Original Vintage

$99.99$49.99

Madballs Mad Balls Snake Bait 1986 Freaky String Topper RARE Vintage Toy

Madballs Mad Balls Snake Bait 1986 Freaky String Topper RARE Vintage Toy

$99.95$49.98

Rare Vintage 1986 AmToy My Pet Monster Mini Topper Hugger Clip On Plush Mint

Rare Vintage 1986 AmToy My Pet Monster Mini Topper Hugger Clip On Plush Mint

$499.99$250.00

AMTOY FUMBLE FOOTBALL HEAD CLIP ON FIGURE 1983 STUFFED ANTHRO TEAM MATES SPORTS

AMTOY FUMBLE FOOTBALL HEAD CLIP ON FIGURE 1983 STUFFED ANTHRO TEAM MATES SPORTS

$12.99$6.50

Lot Of 2 Vtg Amtoy Floppalots 1987 Yellow Patchwork Lion & Blue Patchwork Horse

Lot Of 2 Vtg Amtoy Floppalots 1987 Yellow Patchwork Lion & Blue Patchwork Horse

$16.49$8.24

AMTOY 1983 TEAM MATES CLIP ONS LOVE TENNIS BALL GIRL MOC UNUSED SUPER PICKLE PAL

AMTOY 1983 TEAM MATES CLIP ONS LOVE TENNIS BALL GIRL MOC UNUSED SUPER PICKLE PAL

$24.99$12.49

VINTAGE 1987 AMTOY YELLOW BAGGIE BUNNY STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH TOY SOME FLAWS

VINTAGE 1987 AMTOY YELLOW BAGGIE BUNNY STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH TOY SOME FLAWS

$35.00$17.50

1985 AMTOY Huge Clown Plush Doll Stuffed Animal AMERICAN GREETINGS 28"

1985 AMTOY Huge Clown Plush Doll Stuffed Animal AMERICAN GREETINGS 28"

$40.00$20.00

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original No Cuffs.

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original No Cuffs.

$345.97$172.99